In an effort to share more, and using the new xfruits site (HT: JD Lasica) I’ve rolled up my RSS subs (all 236 238 and counting) into one big feed you can just subscribe to. It’s on the left. There’s a couple of quirky subs in there (my folding bike, for example) but otherwise I think it’s a pretty useful resource, and hope you will too…
Monthly Archives: February 2007
Reporting Tony Blair: inaccuracy or partiality?
How do you get this:
“Tony Blair says his belief in God played a part in deciding to go to war in Iraq. The Prime Minister tells ITV1 he prayed over the difficult decision. Tonight the startling insight into how Mr Blair’s faith influenced Britain’s part in ousting Saddam. So was it holy war?”ITV News Saturday, 4 March 2006
From this:
Tony Blair: The only way you can take a decision like that is to try to do the right thing, according to your conscience. And for the rest of it, you leave it, as I say, to the judgement that …
Michael Parkinson: So…
TB: ….history will make.
MP: So you, so you would… you would… you would… pray…to… to God whenever you make a decision like that?
TB: Well I… you know… I don’t want to go into…
MP: No, but I mean, hey, you said that…
TB: …this side of this but it’s… [NB These two lines spoken simultaneously]
MP: …you said that…you’d…
TB: Yeah I … you, you… [NB These lines also spoken simultaneously]
MP: …been informed…
TB: but you… of course…. It’s…. you, you struggle with your own conscience about it because people’s lives are affected…Michael Parkinson show, Saturday 4 March 2006
According to industry regulator Ofcom, the interpretation placed by ITV News on Tony Blair’s appearance on the Michael Parkinson show broke the regulation on due accuracy.
You can watch the full clip of the interview here. Seeing it is more compelling than reading it, and in my view, whilst ITV News reported Mr Blair accurately, they didn’t report him impartially.
Here’s the ITV intro again:
Tony Blair says his belief in God played a part in deciding to go to war in Iraq. The Prime Minister tells ITV1 he prayed over the difficult decision.
And, here’s the BBC News intro (which gives Parky a bigger plug):
The Prime Minister has said in an interview that he prayed to God when deciding whether or not to send UK troops to Iraq. Tony Blair told ITV1’s Parkinson chat show that he had struggled with his conscience…
The Beeb launch into a Richard Lister package, but then ITV continues with this:
Tonight the startling insight into how Mr Blair’s faith influenced Britain’s part in ousting Saddam. So was it holy war?
ITV took a view on Blair’s exchange with Parkinson and — without exactly mis-representing it — they ‘over-represented’ it, failing to produce anyone in their reporting to defend a position they had created by amplification.
If you’re a Christian, isn’t it right that you pray for guidance over difficult decisions? After all, we’re not talking about consulting a Ouija board. As a firm atheist I know that prayer won’t be delivering anything back, but if we take prayer as a socially acceptable euphemism for reflection, then is there really anything offensive, shocking or surprising about this admission? One doesn’t have to agree with Tony Blair on anything, not least his commitment of troops to Iraq, to tolerate his right to religious freedom.
Still, accuracy is the offence as far as Ofcom is concerned. I guess it’s a less ‘politically sensitive’ crime than impartiality which might make you vulnerable — unfairly — to accusations of stooge-dom. I’d like to see the regulator have a little backbone, and tough it out one of these days…
Incidentally Richard Lister’s report on the BBC didn’t have anyone defending Tony Blair either, but then the BBC piece didn’t shout as loud.
Britain’s free online news battle…
The biggest freesheet battle in the British media is being conducted online. According to the latest stats, the online versions of the Guardian and the Times have both moved up the website ratings. Guardian Unlimited got 16m unique users last month. Over the same period Timesonline.co.uk claimed 11m unique users. Both of these are part of Paul Dacre’s ‘subsidariat.’ Both would, however, like to make money.
Freesheet rivals the BBC News website gets one billion pageviews per month. I don’t know what that translates to in unique users, but just to put that metric in some perspective, Timesonline.co.uk got 74m pageviews and Guardian Unlimited 153m.
Thank goodness they don’t print newspapers at the Beeb’s Wood Lane HQ.
Sky mistake over the news?
Sky aren’t usually naïve, but they’ve lost a lot of potential good will trying to dump the RTS “news channel of the year” from Freeview and then running this ad to kick Virgin…