Carnival of Journalism 2 (Gnostic edition)

January 14, 2008

Actu­ally it’s start­ing to feel more like a blog cara­van than a blog car­ni­val of journ­al­ism as blog­gers hop on board. So what is the journo­sphere up to? First up, gen­er­ously passing on tips:

Else­where thoughts are on journ­al­ism rev­enue mod­els, three words that flow together as eas­ily as “Help, I’m drowning.”

Paul Brad­shaw at the Online Journ­al­ism blog is aim­ing to keep pro­fes­sional heads above water talk­ing enter­prise journ­al­ism. Or actu­ally Journ­al­ism Enter­prise. He’s launch­ing a new blog.

He could do worse than talk­ing to one of Nick Denton’s col­lege con­tem­por­ar­ies — UK sports writer and web­site founder Rick Wag­horn, fea­tured over at journalism.co.uk.

And in case you think these dis­cus­sions are new, Jack Lail hits gold unearth­ing a dis­cus­sion on the future of news­pa­pers from 1997. Does this sound famil­iar?

Bill Bass: “It’s inter­est­ing you talk about news­pa­pers present­ing a com­plete pack­age but, if I go through about any of your news­pa­pers and start look­ing for what was cre­ated loc­ally and how much is pack­aged from other people, the amount of local stuff is van­ish­ingly small.

You take out the wire stor­ies, you take out the stock tables, you take out the clas­si­fied ads, real estate and things like that, and what is left that you people in this room deliver is really a small part of the entire package.”

John Ndege at Scribblesheet writes in praise of magazines, some of which are buck­ing industry trends. And Erica Smith at graphicdesignr.net gets excited about the pos­sib­il­it­ies of SMS.

This would not be blog­ging, of course, if people weren’t get­ting excited about a good meme. Paul Con­ley’s splen­did link­bait You can’t teach cul­ture is the one reel­ing them in.

Pat Thornton at Journ­al­ism Icon­o­clast takes the hook. Although he agrees with Con­ley , he doesn’t quite sug­gest humanely cull­ing dis­sid­ent journos. Pat has a more optim­istic take on the per­fec­tion of human nature online: “I still believe in training.”

Bryan Mur­ley at Innov­a­tion in Col­lege Media takes issue with both Con­ley and Pat:

…ulti­mately, I think you can teach cul­ture. It’s just a much more involved, subtle pro­cess than occurs in your usual classroom environment.”

Alf Her­mida at Reportr.Net also tips his hat to Con­ley:

There is much talk about news­room cul­ture and whether you can teach someone to think digit­ally. Journ­al­ists need to go bey­ond being on the web, and instead be of the web.”

But it’s Andy Dickin­son who takes Conley’s post to an alto­gether higher plane with gnostic journ­al­ism — before rejoin­ing the rest of us in the digital gutter.

Of course, this wouldn’t be journ­al­ism blog­ging without missed dead­lines. Still in the vir­tual pub this time around:

Per­haps there are more enjoy­able things than blogging!

{ 1 comment… read it below or add one }

1 Anonymous January 14, 2008 at 12:59

Oh, bugger!

In after the desk had closed.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: