The death of TV reviewing: an explanation

Television

Why is TV review­ing dying on its knees? The Daily Tele­graph has just bid farewell to its TV reviewer. Is tele­vi­sion no longer worthy of cri­ti­cism? Buzz. Dumb question.

What actu­ally has happened is that review­ing has been bypassed alto­gether. Take Chan­nel 5’s Stran­gelove: Mar­ried to the Eif­fel Tower*, a pro­gramme which fea­tured women who claimed to be mar­ried to — yes — the Eif­fel Tower and the Ber­lin Wall.

24 May: The Inde­pend­ent has a piece from the documentary-maker.

27 May: The Tele­graph car­ries a sober news account of just one of the women — Eija-Riitta Berliner-Mauer. No link to her web­site though.

27 May: The Sun (‘cemen­ted’ the rela­tion­ship, brick-teasers etc.) car­ries a less sober account. The Mir­ror mor­al­ises, invok­ing Sex And The City.

28 May: It makes China Daily.

Guard­ian read­ers might have come across Berliner-Mauer before in Adrian Searle’s account of the Ber­lin Bien­nial, where she is the sub­ject of a film by artist Lars Lau­mann.

Berliner-Mauer turns out to be some­thing of a self-publicist. Back in 1997, as plain old Eija-Riitta Eklof, she was fea­tured in the Inde­pend­ent for her love of guil­lot­ines.

But her own efforts were as noth­ing com­pared to a bit of pre-programme pub­li­city re-packaged and syn­dic­ated. The pro­gramme airs in the UK on 4 June. Review­ing by then will feel a little late…

*Pro­duced by Blink Films, the com­pany set up by former Chan­nel 5 dir­ector of pro­grammes Dan Cham­bers. Small world, telly.

4 thoughts on “The death of TV reviewing: an explanation

  1. The Globe and Mail, out of Toronto, still has one (and I hope for a long time). One of the best TV reviewer I’ve ever come across: John Doyle.

    He’s required read­ing, espe­cially dur­ing the net­work promo tour weeks with all the other TV review­ers in LA.

  2. Will look out for him. The Guard­ian’s Nancy Banks-Smith is a legend, but it does seem like the busi­ness of pro­gramme pro­mo­tion is ren­der­ing it — and its prac­ti­tion­ers — increas­ingly redundant.

  3. Hi Adrian,

    Look at jumptheshark.com — or televisionwithoutpity.com — review­ing is not dying — it seems stronger than ever.

    Maybe these news­pa­pers are just a bit behind like how they got caught out by craigslist on clas­si­fied adverts — any news­pa­per could have star­ted a tele­vi­sion­without­pity web­site, but I’m not sure many gave it much thought…

    Russ

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>